. perial Librar WfrM^ University of California • Berkeley PAULINE FORE MOFFITT LIBRARY //?< ANOTHER'S CRIME ANOTHER'S CRIME FROM THE DIARY OF INSPECTOR BYRNES BY JULIAN HAWTHORNE AUTHOR OF "A TRAGIC MYSTERY," "THE GREAT BANK ROBBERY," "AN AMERICAN PENMAN, "" SEC- TION 558 J OR, THE FATAL LETTER," ETC. CASSELL & COMPANY, LIMITED 104 & 106 FOURTH AVENUE, NEW YORK COPYRIGHT, 1888, By O. M. DUNHAM. Press W. L. Mershon & Co. Rahway, N. J. CONTENTS. CHAPTER I. THE NOLENS, i CHAPTER II. SUITORS, - 12 CHAPTER III. MRS. CUTHBERT TUNSTALL, - - - - 21 CHAPTER IV. NEEDS MUST, - 31 .CHAPTER V. A FATAL MEETING, 41 CHAPTER VI. THE END OF AN INTRIGUE, - 51 CHAPTER VII. VAL MARTIN, - 63 CHAPTER VIII. A REVELATION, - - 71 CHAPTER IX. BAIL, - - 80 CHAPTER X. PAULINE, -------- 89 IV CONTENTS. CHAPTER XI. AT SEA, - - 100 CHAPTER XII. THE SHADOW OF DEATH, - - no CHAPTER XIII. To AWAIT CONFIRMATION, - 123 CHAPTER XIV. A POWERFUL ALLY, - - 133 CHAPTER XV. A MESSAGE FROM THE SEA, - - 143 CHAPTER XVI. A STRANGE WOOING, 153 CHAPTER XVII. A HUNTER'S YARN, ------ 164 CHAPTER XVIII. A DILEMMA, 174 CHAPTER XIX. IN A CARRIAGE, - 184 CHAPTER XX. A CHECK, - - 195 CHAPTER XXI. AT HEADQUARTERS, - - 207 CHAPTER XXII. JOHN CRUSH, ....... 217 CHAPTFR XXIII. THE SHADOW LIFTED, _____ 226 ANOTHER'S CRIME. CHAPTER I. THE NOLENS. IF you could put on the cap of invisibility and sit for twenty-four hours in the private room of Inspector Byrnes at police headquarters, you would see many strange sights. Representatives of every grade of the community pass through those mys- terious portals during the day. All sorts and con- ditions of men, from the depraved pickpocket to the cultured millionaire ; all varieties of the daughters of Eve, from the poor vulgar trull to the refined and lovely queen of society. Here meet youth and age, virtue and vice, industry and idle- ness, wise and foolish, good and evil. Strange events are there brought to light ; life-histories, fantastic, tragic, comic, pathetic, romantic ; crimes startling or sordid ; human passions are there unfolded of every species — love, hate, revenge, avarice, self-abnegation, ambition, and despair, which is the death of all passion, good or bad. 2 THE NOLENS. And what a gallery of faces follow one another, in endless succession, across the threshold — beautiful, hideous, sorrowful, joyful, contented, wretched, cul- tivated, degraded, spiritual, bestial. And all who come have some story to tell, some accusation to bring, some defense to oppose, some end to gain. Having said their say they disperse again — some to liberty, some to trial ; some to death, some to victory ; some to prisons, some to palaces. All the contrasts of human existence, all its lights and shadows, appear in the Inspector's room, and dis- appear again, while you look on in your cap of invisibility. And there, at his desk, sits the Inspector, exam- ining, weighing, deciding, investigating, advising, reproving, encouraging ; cheerful or grave, as the case may be, even-tempered, firm, suave, stern, penetratimg, impenetrable ; the depository of all secrets, the revealer of none ; the man who is never hurried, yet never behind-hand ; never idle, yet never weary ; always patient, and always prompt. No position under the municipal govern- ment requires more tact than his, more energy, more courage, more experience. He must be pli- ant, yet immovable ; subtle, yet straightforward ; keen, yet blunt. He must know all the frailties of human nature, and yet be not too cynical to com- prehend its goodness ; he must be an advocate, and at the same time a judge. In short, he must be a chief of New York detectives ; and, whatever else his office may be, it is certainly no sinecure. THE NOLENS. 3 Of the countless dramas and episodes that come to his knowledge, many can not be told again ; and many, if told, would not be credited, so different from the strangeness of fiction is the strangeness of real life. On the other hand, not a few of these tales can be repeated without indiscretion, and, in all substantial respects, precisely as they actually came to pass. Such narratives have one advan- tage over the conceptions of the imagination, that they are a record of facts, not fancies, and carry the authority and impressiveness of fact. But they also labor under a disadvantage which, per- haps, more than balances the gain of reality ; for facts are stubborn, and accommodate themselves but awkwardly to the rules of artistic construction and symmetry. Like rocks in a New England farm, they are continually cropping up where they are least wanted. And yet, it will sometimes happen that nature so nearly accommodates herself to art that the story assumes a tolerable grace and pro- portion ; and such a one is contained' in the pages that follow. But, although the sequence and char- acter of the events has been adhered to, the names of the persons are changed ; for the affair took place but a short while since, and nearly all the actors in it are still alive, and several of them moving in the best society in New York. Mr. Bartemus Nolen was a representative of a good New York family, and was possessed of com- 4 THE NOLENS. fortable means ; by profession he was a lawyer. He was a member of the Episcopalian Church, and he married, at the outset of his career, a lady of the same persuasion, a woman of excellent educa- tion and gentle and benevolent disposition. The first twenty years of their married life passed hap- pily and prosperously; two sons were born to them ; and a few years later a daughter, Pauline. Mr. Nolen achieved honor and eminence in his profes- sion ; the boys did well in school and afterward at college, and the daughter gave promise of sin- gular intelligence and beauty — a promise which was afterward fulfilled. But at length the current of luck took a turn, and began to set against the honest lawyer. He was affected with a cataract in one of his eyes, which had not proceeded far when the other also showed signs of being affected ; this misfortune was a serious drawback to his practice, and finally compelled him to abandon it almost entirely. Of course, practice meant money, and the cessation from it diminution of income. There was still enough left, however, to live upon with comfort, if not luxuriously ; but unfortunately Mr. Nolen, being deprived of his customary mental employ- ment, took to thinking of other things ; and one of the subjects of his meditation was the feasibility of getting larger returns from his invested property. Among his acquaintance were many men whose trade was finance, and Bartemus got in the habit of counselling with them upon financial matters. No THE NOLENS, 5 doubt they gave him the best advice at their dis- posal ; but when one begins to buy stocks advice is of little use ; and Mr. Nolen, after several ups and downs, came down with somewhat of a thump, to the extent of about a third part of his total pos- sessions. At this juncture he proved his excep- tional good sense and self-control ; for he never risked another dollar in speculation. Neither did he reveal the fact of his losses, which was at least prudent. But these virtues could not save him from being and feeling a good deal poorer than he was before. He owned the house lived in, and continued to live in it ; but he curtailed his expenses, and by strict economy contrived to ren- der them less than his income. His sons would soon be through college, and would then, it was to be supposed, take care of themselves. It was for his daughter that he was saving, and he hoped to leave her at least a decent fortune after his death. But other misfortunes were in store for him. His oldest son, Jerrold Nolen, had graduated from college, and came to New York to study medicine, living, meanwhile, at his father's house. He was a young fellow of ability and agreeable manners, and was popular among his fellows. His father was proud of him, and treated him with partiality. It soon became apparent that Jerrold was rather inclined to dissipation ; his sociable nature had its detrimental side. This was the more unfortunate, inasmuch as he had a tendency to heart disease, and THE NOLENS. was of an excitable temperament. As this matter will be dwelt on hereafter, it is enough to say here that Jerrold died under tragic circumstances in the second year of his medical studies. His death, besides bringing bitter grief to his father and mother, led to legal proceedings against a person supposed to have been instrumental in compassing his destruction—proceedings which led to no good results, and involved a large expense. Mr. Nolen never recovered from the shock and disappoint- ment of his eldest son's sudden end ; and in little more than a year afterwards the morning papers contained respectful but brief notices of his decease. His will was admitted to probate ; it devised twenty thousand dollars to his son Percy Nolen when the latter should come of age; the remainder was settled upon Mrs. Nolen, with certain provisos in the event of Pauline's marrying with her mother's approval. Percy's bequest was intended to start him in business, he having shown a ten- dency to take up mining engineering as a pursuit. He too was an intelligent boy, and left college in good standing as to scholarship, but his character resembled Jerrold's in its lack of firmness and per- sistent energy ; while, unlike Jerrold, he was of a selfish disposition. After graduating and coming into possession of his patrimony, he announced his intention of postponing for awhile his professional studies and seeing a little of metropolitan life. This made his mother anxious, remembering THE NOLENS. 7 the unhappy career of her older son, but she in- terpreted Percy's design in the manner most favorable to him, as simply a wish to become prac- tically familiar with the ways and manners of good society. Percy's original purposes may, indeed, have con- templated no more than that ; but that was far from being the limit of what he actually did. His ad- vances towards the best society were neither con- siderable nor prolonged. For a few months he went to dinners and receptions and danced at balls ; but it soon became evident that he was get- ting intimate with a class of people who, by no stretch of courtesy, could be counted among the upper ten. These were chiefly young men who dressed well, had dash and assurance of manner, and, were commonly to be met with on fashionable thoroughfares, in the corridors and billiard-rooms of the best hotels, on base-ball grounds and race- tracks, and, towards the small hours of the night, at certain restaurants and other places of resort more remarkable for brilliance and liveliness than for respectability, in which the company ceased to be exclusively masculine, and was yet not im- proved by the alteration. Percy had his choice, and this was the class with which he chose more and more to associate. They were, as a class, not wealthy ; nevertheless to be with them was not necessarily to be economical; neither did it involve regular habits or early hours. Before long Percy was convinced that the sort of life he was leading 8 THE NOLENS. was not compatible with making a home under his mother's roof ; so he took bachelor rooms on the west side of the city, and went to bed and got up at what o'clock it best pleased him. He did not keep away from home altogether ; he would drop in now and then, when nothing else was going on, sometimes to lunch, sometimes to dinner, sometimes to accompany his sister to the opera or theatre; but he had cut loose from his mother's apron-strings, and showed no present signs of meaning to come back to them. He was living a fast life, and not the best kind of fast life either. One of the executors of Mr. Bartemus Nolen's will was Judge Odin Ketelle, a gentleman who had at one period been a partner of Nolen's, and had always remained on intimate and friendly terms with the family. He was a man of position and influence, and was quietly and steadily amassing a large fortune. Mrs. Nolen, in her anxiety about Percy, naturally turned to this friend for counsel ; and probably she could not have done better, if she were to do anything. The judge heard her timid and fond complaints, in which she tried to shield the son whose misdeeds she was forced to expose. When she had finished, he sat with his hands folded on the table, and his eyes under their thick eyebrows fixed in thoughtful contemplation, as he had been wont to sit on the bench, when consider- ing some point of law advanced by counsel. " If a boy wants to be a fool, he mostly succeeds in his wish," he remarked after awhile, "Percy THE NOLENS. 9 has a good deal of untamed blood in his composi- tion, and he will probably work it off in his own fashion. His father gave him his money without conditions or restrictions, hoping that the sense of responsibility would sober him ; but it will need more than that. He will spend it— that is, throw it into the gutter — and then we may look for the dawning of reason in him." " I am sure he is a good boy," said his mother. " He is only full of life, and thoughtless." " There is no reason to suppose him actually vicious," the judge replied, " and, that being the case, we may expect that the want of money will bring him to terms. I do not look to see his father's son commit any act that will bring him under the cognizance of the law ; he is, I take it, incapable of any dishonesty ; consequently, when he becomes bankrupt, he must do one of three things : either he will sit down and starve like a gentleman, or he will find some employment that will give him a living, or he will comeback to you, like his prodigal prototype in Holy Writ." " Percy starve ! Oh, Judge !" faltered Mrs. Nolen. " Do not be uneasy ; Percy will not starve," re- turned he with a slight flavor of irony in his tone. " He is not naturally disposed to asceticism, nor has he the kind of pride that would prompt him rather to die than to betray signs of human weakness. On the other hand, he is clever and quick, and could easily pick up an honest livelihood in other ways than by 10 THE NOLENS. pursuing his project of mining, should he find it necessary to forego that. But my own anticipation is, my dear Mary, that he is too lazy, and that his habits of application, such as they were, have become too much broken up to make that course likely. What I do expect is that he will come back to you and ask you to provide for him." " That is all I ask ! " Mrs. Nolen exclaimed. " I have no doubt of it, my dear," answered the Judge with a smile. " But in this connection there is something that I wish to impress upon you very strongly. Do not, as you value his ultimate wel- fare, not to speak of your own, give him any money without first consulting me. If you fail to observe this precaution, depend upon it you will get into trouble. I know what young men are, and how they regard their mothers — as just so much indulgent soft-heartedness to be taken ad- vantage of ! No, it isn't cynicism ; it's the truth ; and so you will find it. Now, what Percy needs is the conviction that there is no choice for him but to work. So long as he thinks that he can be sup- ported without working he will remain idle. It may be hard for you to refuse him, but unless you do you will only work him an ill turn. You are not a rich woman by any means. Bartemus — it is as well you should know it now — lost a large part of his fortune by injudicious investments ; and when you take out of that the sum secured to Pauline as her dower — a sum which, fortunately, neither you nor she can touch for three years to THE NOLENS. n come — you will have left barely enough to live comfortably on. As for Percy's twenty thousand, we may look upon that as being as good as gone ; it is only a question of time, and no very long time. Until it is gone it is no use attempting to influence him. So much for that ! But now, my dear Mary," continued the Judge, changing his tone, " I wish to speak to you on another matter of no small moment to you, to myself — and to Pauline ! " CHAPTER II. SUITORS. MRS. NOLEN'S face, which had assumed an expression of pensive and brooding sadness, brightened at her daughter's name, and she looked up at the judge with an expectant air. " Pauline is now eighteen years old," the latter observed. " As I look back, it seems impossible, but so it is. I remember her as an infant lying in your arms ; and it does not seem to me that I have changed much since then. And yet, Pauline is a woman, and has more character and substance, too, than many a woman of twice her age. What mir- acles time works ! " " She is the best girl in the world ! " said the mother tenderly. " I am much inclined to agree with you," re- sponded the judge. " She is so strong, so clear-sighted, so faithful and upright," pursued Mrs. Nolen. " And yet there is nothing cold or unsympathetic about her. When her emotions are touched, she seems all fire and spirit. I am sure no sister ever loved her brother, nor any daughter her mother, as Pauline loves Percy and me." " I can well believe it. And have you ever seen SUITORS. 13 signs in her of another sort of love — not that of the daughter or the sister ? " " Oh, I am afraid to think of that ! " returned Mrs. Nolen, pressing her white hands nervously together. " It is so easy for a girl to make a mis- take ; and for her a mistake would be fatal ! " " I think she has good sense enough not to fall into any serious error," said the judge, " though I am no less persuaded that, if she loved a man who in himself was worthy of her, she would allow no considerations of merely selfish prudence to pre- vent her union with him. But I was going to ask you," he added, with a certain subdued anxiety in his deep-toned voice, " whether it has come to your knowledge — whether you have any reason to think that she has already met any one who — whom she would be likely to prefer to any one else ? " " I have not thought of it — it has not occurred to me ! " said Mrs. Nolen, with an accent of appre- hension, looking at the judge with wide-open eyes. " It is hardly too soon to take such a possibility into consideration," he returned. " Pauline is mature for her age ; and it is not too much to say that she is one of the most beautiful young women in New York. You take her a good deal into society : she can hardly fail to meet with admira- tion." " Yes, yes, you are right," said the mother. ** Now that you speak of it, I see that such a thing may happen. But she has spoken to me of no one ; and I am sure she would have spoken, if — " 14 SUITORS. " Do not trust too much to that," he interposed. " A young girl, with a mind as healthy and pure as hers, does not readily ask herself if she be in love ; she may become so before she is aware of it, and only the avowal of her lover will open her eyes. Till then, you cannot expect her to speak of it to you. And then, if she have made up her mind, it would be too late to speak." " But would you advise me to question her ? Might it not suggest to her something which she otherwise would not have thought of ? " " That is not improbable. But why not approach the matter from the other side ? Is there no one among the young men who know her who have shown signs of any particular interest in her ? " " They all seem to admire her," said Mrs. Nolen. " But I can think of no one in particular — unless it be Percy's friend, Mr. Martin." " Valentin^ Martin — the young Englishman ? " " Yes. Percy sometimes brings him here. But his being a friend of Percy makes a difference between him and the others." "How so?" " In the fact of his being here oftener. I mean, if it were not for that I should think his visits had some further significance." " I am not altogether convinced that his being a friend of Percy would deprive his visits of signifi- cance," said the judge. " It is conceivable, at any rate, that he might have made a friend of Percy in orrder to facilitate his access to Pauline." SUITORS. 15 "He seemed a frank, straightforward young man, not one you would suspect of doing any thing underhand." The judge laughed ; a very low, pleasant laugh he had, which made those who heard it disposed at once to like him. " You are more like a nun, in your unsuspiciousness and unworldliness, than like a married woman who goes in New York society," said he. " Let me assure you, my dear, that a man in love is not to be held a criminal, or even a hypo- crite, if he uses some strategy to get near the object of his affection. I should forgive Mr. Martin even if he went so far as to pretend a cordiality for Percy that he did not really feel, if so he might induce Percy to admit him to the intimacy of your household. No, if we are to take exceptions to him, it must be from another standpoint. What do you know about his personal history and his social standing in his own country ? " " I suppose it must be good," said Mrs. Nolen. " I think he said that his family owned a large estate in Cumberland." " Is he the eldest son ? " " The next to the eldest, I believe." " And what is his business in America ? " " I don't know. But a great many English peo- ple come here nowadays, you know. It is a part of their education." " Yes ; but some of them are pretty well educated before they get here," remarked the judge drily, " and occasionally they manage to teach us some- 1 6 SUITOXS. thing before they leave. There is, in England, the same difference between an eldest son and the other sons that there is between a rich man and a pauper. By the law of primogeniture the estates, and generally the bulk of the money, goes to the first-born ; the other boys get positions, if they can, in the army, the civil service, or the church. They, are seldom fitted to enter the learned professions ; and it is not considered good form for a gentleman's son to go into trade. Of course the army and the church don't afford accommodation for all appli- cants ; and the consequence is that every year a num- ber of young Englishmen are thrown on the world, who by training and inclination are good for nothing but to be idle and ornamental, and who neverthe- less have no means for honestly leading such a life. They form a class of gentleman adventurers. They are men of agreeable manners and culture, talk well, look well, are excellent at cards and billiards, and live no one knows how. Some of them come over here, for reasons known only to themselves ; they are very pleasant acquaintances ; but it is well not to trust them too far. They have no fixed place in the world, and no responsibility." "You don't mean that Mr. Martin is — an adven- turer ? " demanded Mrs. Nolen, in a voice of faint consternation. " So far as I know, he may be the best fellow in England. But I know nothing about him, one way or the other. How did Percy become acquainted with him ? " SUITORS. 17 " He met him somewhere, — at some club, I imagine." " That may be all right, or it may not. At all events, you will see that you should proceed with some circumspection. The rules that apply to our young men do not necessarily apply to foreigners. Mr. Martin may be much better educated, and have more polished and quiet manners, than nine out of ten of your American acquaintances ; and yet it might be better that Pauline should marry the least attractive of the latter than Mr. Mar- tin." " I wish you would see him, and find out whether he is nice," said Mrs. Nolen, with anxious earnest- ness. " I would willingly do so, but for one reason," the judge replied, " and that is that the peculiar circumstances might disqualify me from forming an unbiassed opinion." " Oh, I am not afraid of that. My husband used to say that there could be no one more impartial and just than you." " Even assuming that judgment of his to have been impartial, I should nevertheless be disquali- fied from presiding at a trial where, for instance, the prisoner was charged with the murder of some friend of my own." " I do not understand. Mr. Martin has surely not murdered any one ? " " Bless me, no ! I was only using an extreme illustration. But Mr. Martin might wish to obtain 1 8 SUITORS. something which I had set my own heart on pos- sessing." There was a manifest embarrassment in the judge's manner. Mrs. Nolen looked puzzled. She began to suspect there was something behind all this, but she could not divine what it was. " I began life pretty early, as you know," con- tinued he, after a pause. " Since the age of four- teen, I believe, I have supported myself. Measur- ing my existence by that standard, I might be called an old man. But though, in the matter of years, I am not exactly a boy, yet I am but forty- three years old, and you will admit, my dear, that men have been known to live a good deal longer than that." " I am sure you will live to be twice forty-three," put in Mrs. Nolen kindly. " Half that is all I would ask, if I might real- ize the happiness that I hope for," returned the judge, with a faint smile. " And is this happiness any thing that I can help to insure you ? " '• I can hardly say that. In fact, it is essential, in one way, that it should come, if it come at all, as freely and spontaneously as the sunshine from heaven. Nevertheless, I am under obligation to speak to you of my hopes, that you may appreciate my position and understand my conduct." He stopped, and the color mounted to his face. " I love Pauline," he said, a strong emotion vibrating SUITORS. 19 in his voice. " I hope to make her love me and to accept me for her husband." " Oh, Judge ! " exclaimed Mrs. Nolen, taken wholly by surprise. She looked at him intently for a few moments, and then the startled look in her face softened, and she began to smile. She left her chair, and, coming to where he sat, put a hand upon his shoulder ; and as he looked up at her she bent down and kissed him upon the forehead. She was still smiling, but there were tears in her eyes. " Do you think me absurd ? " said the judge. " I think you are right," was her reply. " At first I could not believe — I had always looked up to you as to a sort of elder brother — I could not imagine you as the husband of my little daughter — my own son-in-law. But I think you are right. Pauline is a little girl no longer ; in almost every thing but years she is older than I ; she is fitted to be the wife of a man even so much older than her- self as you are. No one of her own age would suit her as well." " Then you will not be against me ? " he said, starting up. " Indeed, I will not. All that I do shall be done for you." SJk^f put her hands in his, and he grasped them warmly. " It is more than half self- ishness in me," she added. " It would give me some right to rely on you. I should not feel so lonely." " However this may turn out, always know that you may rely on me," the judge returned, with 20 SUITORS. deep feeling. " Our friendship began long ago, Mary, and doesn't need any other tie to bind it. If Pauline, when the question is put before her, decides against me — and I am fully aware how easily that may be her verdict — I shall accept it like a man, and you will remember that, so far as I am con- cerned, it will involve not the slightest change in my devotion to you and yours. I shall leave no honorable means untried to win her ; but, above all things, I desire to avoid forcing her inclination, either by any act of my own, or through you. That you should approve of my purpose is all I ask. Leave the rest to Providence, and to her." " I understand," said Mrs. Nolen, " and, indeed, if I wished to help you, I should not do it by sing- ing your praises to her. You being what you are, the best thing to do is to leave her to find you out for herself." " If Mr. Martin be my rival," resumed the judge, let him have his chance, and defeat me if he can. If he be the better man, it will appear ; and God forbid that I should make her my wife, knowing that she would have been happier with another. But if love go for any thing, I love her well, and in all my life she is the first and only woman I have loved." " You might have rivals more dangerous than Mr. Martin," returned the mother, with another smile ; and so the interview came to a close. CHAPTER III. MRS. CUTHBERT TUNSTALL. "T7 VENTS were shaping themselves for disaster ; JH/ but, for the time being, they seemed to go smoothly enough. Percy Nolen maintained his brilliant career, and attained a certain distinction among the persons with whom he associated. He was a big, hand- some youth, with broad shoulders and sturdy limbs, a clever boxer, a good whip, a fair billiard player ; his spirits were exuberant, and he had more mental resources and ideas than are vouchsafed to the generality of young gentlemen of his kind. Thus he assumed, to some extent, the position of a leader among them ; and, as he was uniformly good- natured and yet not to be imposed upon, he was liked and not laughed at. But his favorite companion and friend was Val- entine Martin. The two men were nearly the same age, Martin being a little the elder, and were a good deal alike in size and personal appearance. Martin, being English, wore side-whiskers, and Percy, being American, wore a mustache. tMar- tin was inclined to be fair, and Percy to be dark ; but they might have been taken to be brothers. 22 MRS. CUTHBERT TUNSTALL. The Englishman, however, was of a somewhat gloomier temperament than the American ; more reticent, and more given to moods and ine- qualities of temper. He had brought with him several good letters of introduction, and had duly delivered them ; but he had availed himself but sparingly of the social courtesies extended to him, seeming to prefer a less formal and regular life. He made no pretense of large wealth, but, on the other hand, he never seemed to be cramped for means, and no one could be found from whom he had borrowed money. If he were a trifle mys- terious, nobody was concerned to fathom his mys- tery, for it was no one's interest to do so. Valen- tine Martin had not come to America to speculate, to organize a company, to raise capital, or to do any of those things that are apt to render engaging foreigners suspicious in our eyes. He had appa- rently come to amuse himself, and mind his own affairs ; and after a time he was permitted to fol- low this innocent inclination. The upper ten, whom he neglected, ceased to take an active interest in him, and those with whom he associated relin- quished the vain effort to persuade him to reveal his secret, and came to the sensible conclusion that there was probably no secret to reveal. The acquaintance and subsequent friendship between Martin and Percy Nolen had sprung up spontaneously, without any formal introduction. They had tastes and ideas in common, and they mutually pleased one another. Martin's was per- MRS. CUTHBERT TUN STALL. 23 haps the stronger character, but Percy's was the more enterprising and lively ; so that they were upon fairly even terms. One day the Englishman accepted an invitation to come and take afternoon tea at the Nolens' ; he met Pauline on that occasion, and it was not afterwards necessary to urge him to repeat his visit. Pauline was inter- ested in him as an Englishman, and after discuss- ing his native country with him admitted him to a certain degree of friendship, partly on her brother's recommendation, partly on his own account. He seemed gloomy at times, and she was sorry for him, without knowing, or even caring to inquire, what made her so. At other times he conversed in a manner that interested her and stimulated her to talk in return; and, though Pauline was but a girl, she had a mind that was worth coming in contact with. The Englishman never made any direct demand upon her sympathies or emotions, and probably he gained rather than lost by this forbearance. When a woman has insight, she would rather exercise her intuitions than have things explained to her. Matters went on in this manner for several months, and the year's vacation which Percy had allowed himself was more than up. He had as yet shown no sign of being bankrupt, unless a certain abstraction of manner at times, accompanied by a biting of his nails, and a drumming with his foot, might be construed as symptoms of approaching impecuniosity. But another affair, not connected 24 MRS. CUTHBEKT TUN STALL. with finance, was going on at this period which, unless put an end to betimes, might result in trouble. There was a young married woman in New York society named Mrs. Cuthbert Tunstall. Her husband, also young, had inherited from his father an immense business in coal. Cuthbert Tunstall was fond of activity, and he plunged into his coal with hearty good-will, intent upon creating a fortune twice as large as that which his father had left him. As a matter of course, and of neces- sity, he was absent all day at his office, and was often obliged to run down to the mines to oversee things there in person. His wife was the daughter of an aristocratic Knickerbocker family ; she had been a reigning belle in her coming-out year, and the year follow- ing the match between her and Tunstall had been made. She liked her husband, because he was a good fellow, because he was in love with her, and because he was considered a big catch ; but she cared nothing for coal, and was jealous of his devotion to it. She wanted him to be devoted to her and to nobody else. She hated to think of him working — actually working — all day long. He came home to dinner, it was true ; but he was not fond of dining out, and when dinner was over, he was tired, and liked to stay quietly at home and go to bed at half-past ten. Such an existence as this was the next thing to unendurable to a woman like Sylvia Tunstall. Forty years hence, perhaps, this Darby-and-Joan kind of life might be practi- MAS. CUTHBERT TUN STALL. 25 cable ; but not now, in the flush of youth, variety, and curiosity ! She absolutely would not stand it ! Tunstall was a manly, straightforward, single- hearted fellow, and at first he did not comprehend his wife's attitude. He had homely ideas of mar- ried life, and the routine of social dissipation.was without attractions for him. When at last he learnt how matters stood, he thought it over, and came to the conclusion that his wife had much reason on her side. She was young, good look- ing, and full of the wine of life, and it was only nat- ural and proper in her to wish to see and to be seen. So he began by attempting to " go out " with her ; but he presently discovered that going to bed at two o'clock in the morning was not compatible with having breakfast at half-past seven. He then tried giving dinners twice a week and a reception once a month ; but Sylvia pointed out to him that the customs of good society demanded that they should accept invitations as well as give them : so that his second state bade fair to be even worse than his first. What was to be done ? He would not consent to give up his business ; on that point he was firm. Sylvia was equally convinced that it was impossible to give up society. For a time there threatened to be a deadlock. Finally a compromise was effected. Sylvia had relations, and particular friends, who were in so- ciety, and of whose escort and countenance she could avail herself. Her husband could take her to places, and her relatives or friends could bring 26 MRS. CUTHBERT TUNST&LL. her home again. By degrees it was found unneces- sary to have him take her, and she both went and returned without him. His anticipations of domestic felicity were disappointed ; but Sylvia was enjoying herself, and he always looked forward to a,time when she would weary of gayety and return to him. He loved her as much as ever, and was proud of her social popularity ; he had perfect faith in her truth and honor. He ate his dinner and went to bed alone, and when he rose in the morning he was careful not to awaken his wife. That was the style of the menage. But Cuthbert Tunstall was not a fool— a fact which his wife perhaps failed to fully appreciate. As long as her conduct was above reproach, accord- ing to the somewhat vague standards of society, he would not interfere with her pleasures ; but he was not the man to permit the least step beyond this. And though he was naturally unsuspicious, and slow to wrath, any one who understood men would have known that it would be uncomfortable to arouse him. But Sylvia got the idea that she could do exactly as she pleased ; and she did it. One day, Tunstall got a hint from some precious friend of his — a very distant, indirect, ambiguous, and innocent hint, but a hint all the same. He appeared not to understand it, and passed it over without comment ; but the repressed emotion which it aroused was so strong that he came near faint- ing where he stood. He attended to his business the same as usual, MRS. CUTHBERT TUN STALL. 27 returned home at his customary hour, and sat clown to his solitary dinner. His wife was upstairs, dressing. By and by she came down to say good- by to him for the evening, She was beautifully dressed, and was lovely to look upon. Cuthbert looked at her in silence. " Good-night, dear," she said, drawing on her gloves. " I suppose you won't be up when I come home." " Not if you come at your usual time." u I wish you'd drop your horrid business, and come with me." " I am more useful as I am. Do you know a gentleman by the name of Percy Nolen ? " " Percy Nolen ? No — yes — I believe I do." These were her words ; but her face, and the tone of her voice, betrayed her ; and they both knew it. " He is an agreeable fellow, isn't he ? " pursued the husband, quietly. " I suppose he is like the rest ; all men are alike to me — except you, of course, dear ! But why do you ask ? " '• Some one who knows him happened to mention him to-day. Well, and what is going on to-night ? " " Dine at Mrs. Murray's, and then the theatre." " Won't you want something to eat when you get home ? " " Oh, no. Don't bother. I shan't be hungry." " It might be better to order something to be ready for you here than to take supper at Del- ^ MRS. CUTHBERT TUN STALL. monico's," he said slowly, looking her in the eyes. She turned away her eyes after a moment, ostensi- bly to pull up her cloak. " I had no idea of going to Delmonico's," she said, in a slightly strained voice. " Of course not ! " he repeated ; and then he turned to his evening paper, and she went out, with a smile on her lips, and fear in her heart. Her husband had given her warning, and he hoped against hope that it would be sufficient. He would not take the next step unless she compelled him to it; but he was resolved (and she partly felt it) that the next step would be final. How much he actually knew of her .flirtation with Percy she could of course only conjecture. She had taken sup- per with him in. a private room of a fashionable res- taurant the night before. They had not been alone : there had also been present another young married woman ; and a young man not married. But the two couples had not been in each other's way, they had rather helped each other out. It was certainly not an affair which Sylvia would have wished to have generally known — least of all to be suspected by her husband. Did he know about it ? or had his questions been only the result of chance ? She wished to believe the latter, but she could not. There had been something in the very quietness of his tone and manner that had appalled her. She had not thought that he had it in him to frighten her. Evidently she had been too careless — too thought- less. After all, she did not seriously care for MRS. CUTHBERT TUtfSTALL. 29 Percy Nolen. It had been a mere flirtation for pastime. She had not supposed that her husband would care much, even if he knew. He had not, of late, betrayed any very passionate affection for her, If he loved her, why did he not accompany her on her social rounds ? It was ridiculous to say that he was obliged to attend to his business. They had plenty of money without any business. There was nothing, except his own obstinacy, to prevent him from retiring- to-morrow and never going near his office again. But if he preferred his business to his wife, why could he not allow his wife her prefer- ences ? It was unjust and tyrannical. Nevertheless, if he was determined to be ugly about it of course there must be no scandal. She would tell Percy, the next time she saw him, that the acquaintance must cease. It was not worth while to run any risks on his account. Having made up her mind to this, she was more at ease. After the second act at the theatre, Percy Nolen came into her box. She greeted him coldly, but he sat down beside her, and began to make various propositions. She repulsed him, but not very vigorously. At last she whispered, " You must really be more careful ! People are beginning to observe us. If any thing should happen, I would never forgive you ! " " I will take every precaution, but — I love you ! " he replied in her ear. He had never said so much before, and she turned pale and gave him a look. .30 MXS. CUTHBERT TUNSTALL. The curtain went up on the next act, show- ing how the hero, by a combination of circum- stances, was arrested and taken to Police Head- quarters. CHAPTER IV. NEEDS MUST. JUDGE KETELLE'S prophecy was delayed; but it came true at last ; and Mrs. Nolen did not keep her promise to him. One morning Percy came to the house, and came up to his mother's boudoir, where she was sitting reading Mr. Shorthouse's romance of " John Inglesant." Mrs. Nolen was not given to reading fiction as a rule ; but Mr. Shorthouse was under- stood to be a religious writer, and she enjoyed his book very much without entirely understanding it. Percy kissed her, and sat down in a chair opposite. After a little desultory conversation he said " Mother, I'm in a scrape ! " Her heart sank ; she closed her book, and folded her hands upon it. " Oh, my son ! " she said, falteringly. " Well, it's nothing so very dreadful," he returned, forcing a smile. " I was up at Monmouth Park the other day, and lost a little money — well, it was a pretty good sum, for me. I'm not a Croesus, you know, and a few thousand dollars makes a dif- ference." 32 NEEDS MUST. " Monmouth Park ? What is that ? " " It's a track ; they race horses there, you know." " Percy, have you been betting on horse-races ? " " Mercy, mother, it's no crime ! All the fellows do it. I should look queer if I didn't chip in with the rest ! Only this time I happened to get in pretty deep ; and as all the favorites were beaten I got badly left." " Do you mean that you lost all the money you wagered ?" " Every cent of it ; you never saw such a run of bad luck in your life. The trouble was, I made up my mind to win anyhow ; so each time I lost I put it all on the next race, so as to get back what was gone, and more into the bargain. It was as good as certain that I wouldn't lose every race, you see. So when it came to the last I had a big pile on ; and it was voted a sure thing. I believe it was the jockey's fault, after all. Anyhow, he lost the race by a short head ; and if I hadn't had a return ticket I'd have been obliged to walk home." " All your money gone ! Why, my son, if you had invested it, you might have lived comfortably on the interest of it ! And your father gave it to you to start you in your profession. What can you do ? " " Well, mother, I must do the best I can. I know it's all wrong, and I'm very sorry, and all that. But it's no use crying for spilt milk. I'm in a hole, and I've got to be helped out of it, somehow ! " " I will speak to Judge Ketelle, and see what — " " Whatever you do, don't speak to Judge Ketelle ! NEEDS MUST. 33 He can do no good, and would be certain to do a lot of mischief. What business is it of Judge Ketelle's, anyway ? " " He was appointed executor under the will, and — " " That is no concern of mine, mother. My interest in the will ceased when I got my patrimony. I have no further relations with the judge, nor he with me. He has no right to help me, even if he wanted to, which he doesn't." " My son, he is the best friend I have, and what- ever is for our good— " My dear mother, I tell you it won't do ! I know what the judge would say, and after he had said it I would be no better off than I am now. I have some pride, and I don't want all the world to know that I'm a beggar. I shouldn't think you would, either." " Percy, you know I wish nothing but your good, but — " " The long and short of the matter is that unless I am to be disgraced. I must have some money, and without any delay, too. I owe a few bills — they don't amount to much — and I must Jiave a little to go on with. A thousand dollars would cover the whole thing. You can let me have it, can't you ?" " A thousand dollars ! But after that, Percy ? You will be wanting money all the time, and this cannot go on forever." " It isn't going on forever. This is the first time 34 iVEEDS MUST. I have ever asked you for a cent, mother, and it shall be the last. Heaven knows, it was hard enough to have to come to you at any rate ; but I didn't expect you would make it harder by arguing about it ! " " My dearest boy, you might have all 1 possess, so far as I am concerned — " " Who else is concerned except you ? a thousand dollars isn't going to ruin you, mother, but. it is ruin to me if I don't get it. And don't fear I shall be coming to you again. I am going to stop the kind of life I have been living the last year, and turn over a new leaf. I have several opportunities to get positions in the city, and I am going to set to work at once and find out what will be the best thing. As soon as I am in a place where I can turn around, I shall put in my spare time study- ing up my mining, and before another year is out, I shall be ready to accept an engagement. I can support myself as well as the next man — and make a fortune, too ! But I don't suppose you want to see me miss all that for the sake of a paltry thou- sand dollars ? " The grid of it was that Mrs. Nolen gave him a thousand dollars. She tried to make him promise that he would come and live under her own roof ; but he put her off with a temporizing reply, alleg- ing, in no very logical vein, that he did not wish to make himself a burden to her ; but when he got " fixed " so that he could pa)^ her for his board and lodging he would come with pleasure. NEEDS MUST. 35- The request indicated that getting fixed was an operation that required time. The fact was that Percy paid sums on account to his most pressing creditors, including the proprietor of his lodgings, and went on living much as before ; to salve his conscience he did make some inquiries about work, but not in such a manner as to secure prac- ticable answers. One subject possessed his mind, and that was Mrs. Tunstall. It was impossible for him to live with his mother while that affair was going on. His infatuation was intensified by Sylvia's timidity and reluctance. A man's brains count for nothing in such a matter. Percy lived in the desire of the moment ; he gave no thought to the inevitable consequences. If he might see her to-day, or to-morrow, no matter about the day after, and no matter that the meeting was fraught with danger both to her and to him. The differ- ence between a good desire and an evil one gener- ally is that the former is sane and the latter has more or less of insanity. Sylvia's heart was not engaged — if she could be said to have a heart — and it was clear in her mind that she must run no risk of compromising herself. At the same, had it been in her power to banish Percy forever by the utterance of a single word, it is doubtful if she would have done it. She knew that, were her husband to discover any further correspondence between them, he would not hesi- tate to act decisively and finally, and the first result of that action would be that she would find 36 NEEDS MUST. herself cast upon the world with a damaged repu- tation. Such a thing was not to be thought of. But the very peril of her position was an allure- ment to linger in it ; and then there was the excite- ment of knowing that a man was in love with her who had no business to be so, and who was willing to go all lengths for her. Moreover, she was angry as well as dismayed because her husband had spoken to her as he did (like all women, she inter- preted what was said by what was meant), and found a pleasure in defying him in thought if not in deed. So, although she did not openly and explicitly encourage Percy, she allowed him to believe that he was not indifferent to her. Neither he nor she had committed any actual sin, but they were on the road to do so. People always believe that they can pull up at the last moment, and are therefore willing to go on until the last moment is reached. But by that time events combine in an unforeseen manner and push them over the edge. Then they are astonished to find themselves linked with the brotherhood of crime. And, once that link is forged, it defies all attempts to break it. It happened before long that Percy needed more money. He had less than two hundred dollars left, and he owed more than that. He did not wish to go to his mother again, partly from shame, partly because he knew that, in order to raise the sum he needed, she would be obliged to sell some stock, and that would involve applying to Judge Ketelle. NEEDS MUST. 37 One night, at a club, he was asked to take a hand at a game of poker with three others. He sat down and played with varying success for an hour or two. Then two of the quartette withdrew, and he and the other kept on. Percy had faith in his luck, and had fortified himself with several whiskey cocktails. His op- ponent was a quiet man, and seemed to be in a dejected and timid frame of mind. The chips on the table represented a good deal of money, how much exactly Percy did not know ; he meant to win it all. Some good cards were dealt to him ; he drew, and found himself in possession of a superb hand. He was quite certain that his adver- sary held no such cards, and he began to bet. His adversary was drawn into raising him ; they con- tinued to raise each other. Percy swallowed an- other cocktail, and felt that he could not lose. He acted upon this conviction, and lost. Upon in- vestigation, it appeared that the quiet man had won not only Percy's original stakes but some nine hundred dollars into the bargain. Percy preserved a calm exterior, and wrote his I. O. U. for the amount, to be redeemed within twenty-four hours. Meanwhile, he was in a cold sweat of consternation, for he did not know how he was to get the money. It was too large a sum to borrow from any of his acquaintances : those whom he knew well enough to approach on such a matter were aware of his financial standing, and would not lend any thing. There was nothing for 38 XEEDS MUST. it but to go to his mother. The money must be forthcoming. If he failed to pay, he would be dis- honored ; Sylvia would hear of it. ... No ! he must have the money at any cost. He went to bed, passed a very bad night, and after attempting to eat some breakfast he betook himself to his mother's house. The nature of his errand was so apparent in his manner and appear- ance that she divined it at once. The interview that ensued was a very painful one to both parties. Mrs. Nolen had not got the money, and could not get it for a week at least. She convinced her son by documentary evidence that such was the case. It might be possible to borrow from Judge Ketelle ; there was no other way. These were facts which no arguments or entreaties could alter. Mrs. Nolen was terribly agitated by the revelation of her son's incorrigible perversity, and her tears and anguish put him in almost a suicidal frame of mind. It seemed to him that if he could only es- cape from this predicament he would never allow himself to get caught again. But there was no es- cape, except through the judge, and that was al- most as bad as no escape at all. The judge, even if he agreed to the loan, was not the man to spare Percy a plain and severe statement of the repre- hensibility of his behavior. The young man writhed in anticipation of this rebuke. He knew he deserved it, but it would not be easier to endure on that account. Under ordinary circumstances he might rebel and answer back ; but it would not NEEDS MUST, 39 do to fight with a man whom he was begging money of. He had always been proud of his pride ; now that pride was going to suffer a fatal humilia- tion. Only one thing could be worse, and that was to inform his opponent of the night before that he could not pay him. Percy wished that he had never been born, and then he wished that he were dead. The first wish being impracticable, and the second one that he did not care to put into practice, he left his mother's house in an unenviable frame of mind, and turned his steps in the direction of Judge Ketelle's office. He felt gloomy and desperate. He could understand how men, heretofore respec- table, were induced to become thieves or robbers. Had he been a bank-cashier, he felt that he was in a mood to rob the safe and depart for Canada : or if he had been alone on a dark road with a wealthy old gentleman, he could have taken him by the throat and gone through his pockets. But he was on Fifth Avenue, in broad daylight, and these short methods of reimbursing himself were not available. He struck into Broadway, and presently, about a block in advance, he caught sight of a graceful female figure that he knew, walking in the same direction with himself. It was Sylvia Tunstall. He hastened his steps : but just before he came up with her she turned into a large jewelry shop on the right. It was as good a place as another for an inter- 4° XEEDS MUST. view, and he felt a feverish desire to speak to her. He followed her into the shop, and, as she came to a pause at one of the counters, he stood beside her and uttered her name. CHAPTER V. A FATAL MEETING. rHE shop was a very large one, and was full of customers, for the holiday season was at hand, and the wealthier portion of the community was presenting itself with precious gifts. The custom- ers were chiefly ladies, though there was also a fair sprinkling of the other sex. There were also the salesmen and the walkers, and perhaps a few other persons whose office was not to promote sales but to prevent appropriations of stock by individ- uals who had not gone through the formality of paying for it. Yet it seemed impossible that, among such a multitude, the eyes of a detective should be able to fix upon the malefactors, and nevertheless a successful theft was a very uncom- mon occurrence in the great jewelry shop. When Mrs. Tunstall heard her name, she turned with a start, and her vivid but pretty face paled. " Don't stay," she said in a low voice ; " do go ! what is the use of running any risks ? " " I have as good a right as anybody to be here," Percy replied. "If we both happen to be here at the same time, what of that ? " 42 A FATAL MEETING. " What is the matter ? You look quite ill ! " she said. At this moment a salesman, having despatched an adjoining customer, presented himself before her with a " What can I do for you, madam?" She handed him a card and said, " I have called about that necklace ; it was to have been ready this morning." The man took the card, bowed, and hurried off. She turned again to Percy. Her muff was in her left hand ; and as she turned she laid it upon the glass counter, on the side furthest away from him. His sudden appearance had evi- dently disconcerted her. He met her look, and thought how charming she was. She was dressed in fine black velvet, trimmed with soft furs, and wore a wonderful bonnet, adorned with birds' feathers and sparkling points ; a delicate silken veil was bound around it. Her oval face, with its bright eyes, small straight nose and rather full lips, was perfectly pretty ; and now the blood, which had been driven from her cheeks for a moment, came ebbing back beneath the trans- parent skin. She was lovely, luxurious, and rich; those diamonds in her ears would have paid all his debts, and he believed that she would relieve his necessities in a moment had she known of them. But how impossible it was to tell her ! How inaccessible she was, though he could have thrown his arms around her as she stood there ! He felt a helpless rage — an impulse to seize upon her and make off with her bodily. If he only had had A FATAL MEETING. 43 money — money, and plenty of it — there was nothing so wild that he would not have ventured to propose it to her. What a power money was in this world ! All this time he stood gazing at her, and saying not a word. " What is the matter with you, Percy ? " she repeated. " What makes you look so ? you are making every body notice us. Are you — " she hesitated. " I am sober, if that's what you mean," he said. " If we were alone, I would show you what is the matter with me ! Good God ! is there no place in the world where we can be alone together for half an hour ! " Some one touched him on the arm. He turned savagely. It was only a gentleman who begged his pardon ; he had left a cane standing against the counter. It was not there ; he apologised and went off. Percy came round to the other side of Sylvia, and leaned on the counter, taking her muff in his hands. " I can't stand this," he resumed. " I never see you at all now. I have as much right to see you as any of your acquaintances. You keep out of my way ! " " If you would be content to see me as my other acquaintances do — but you know perfectly well how dangerous it is. And you could not have chosen a worse place than this." She bent forward and added in a whisper, " I expect Mr. Tunstall may come in at any moment. He knew I was coming 44 A FATAL MEETING. here this morning about the necklace, and said something about intending to try and meet me. Do go ! It will only make it more difficult here- after." " It cannot be more difficult than it is already," replied Percy sullenly. " I should like to meet him and have it out with him, if he wants to say anything ! What is there he can say, for that mat- ter? He has no business to interfere." " You don't know him ! " " He doesn't know me, if he thinks I care for him ! Why should we mind ? If the worst comes to the worst, it would only throw us together. I am ready for it — are you ? " " Percy, you are crazy ! How can you talk so ! You will make me wish never to see you again. Nothing of that sort is possible. I never thought of such a thing." " Such things have been thought of, and they are possible. You are not happy as you are now, Sylvia, and you know it. Why not let society and respectability go to the devil, where they belong, and enjoy life in our own way? There are other places in the world besides New York, or America ? " " Here is the necklace, Mrs. Tunstall," said the voice of the salesman. He was standing on the opposite side of the counter, with the box in his hands. She was thankful for the interruption, for she was becoming seriously alarmed at Percy's manner ; and, drawing the box towards her, she opened it. A FATAL MEETING. 45 It contained a necklace of fine diamonds, which had been selected some time before, and set accord- ing to Mrs. Tunstall's directions. She examined them, and expressed her approval. " It is twenty- five hundred dollars, is it not ? " she said. " Twenty-five hundred dollars," repeated the salesman, softly. She looked around for her muff, which Percy had just replaced on the counter. She slipped her hand in it and uttered an exclamation. Then she sent a quick glance over the counter and on the floor. " Have you seen it ? " she said, in a startled tone. " I beg your pardon ! " said the salesman, blandly. Percy maintained a gloomy silence and an abstracted gaze. " My pocket-book — and some money in bank notes. I had them in my muff," she exclaimed. " Have you — " she went on, turning to Percy. He looked at her uncomprehendingly. " What is it ?" he demanded. " My purse — and the money. Why, you had my muff just now. Didn't you — " " Did I have your muff ? I wasn't aware of it. I know nothing about it," said he, unconcernedly. " But I can't lose it — it must be found — it was right there ! " she exclaimed again. " It can't have disappeared into nothing ! " " May I inquire if the sum was a large one ? " put in the salesman, softly. " Why, yes ! there were twenty-five hundred dol- 4 A FATAL MEETING. lars and some smaller notes in the purse. I had brought it to pay for the necklace." By this time several persons had collected, drawn by the evident agitation of the handsome young lady ; among them was a small, bright-looking man, with an alert and confident manner. He subjected Mrs. Tunstall and Percy to a keen but unobtrusive scrutiny. " Perhaps you put it in your pocket," Percy suggested, who, on hearing so large a sum men- tioned, had begun to arouse himself from his curi- ous apathy. She put her hand in the pocket of her dress and felt in it anxiously, then shook her head. " No," she said, " and, besides, I recollect it all now distinctly. I put the money in my purse when I went out this morning, and put the purse in my muff, as I always do. When I got here I took out the purse and took the notes from it — " " Pardon me, madam," interposed the bright- looking man at this point ; " I am connected with this establishment, and it is my duty to investigate cases of missing articles. Can you state what was the denomination of the bills representing the sum of money — twenty-five hundred dollars I think you said ? " " There were four bank-notes," Mrs. Tunstall re- plied ; " one of a thousand dollars, and three of five hundred each." " Thank you," said the man, making a note on some tablets in his hand. " Do you recollect A FATAL MEETING. 47 the numbers of the notes, or the banks they be- longed to ? " She shook her head. " I didn't look," she said. " You took these notes out of your purse, you say — " " I took them out so as to have them ready. I was a little nervous about carrying so much money, and I thought, if I should lose the purse, I would have the money separate. But now it is all gone ! " " After taking the notes out of your purse, what did you do with them ? " pursued the bright-looking man. " I held them in my hand in my muff ; in this hand," indicating her left. " Then, just as I came up to the counter, this gentleman spoke to me." " This gentleman is a friend of yours ? " Mrs. Tunstall hesitated and colored. " I am acquainted with him — slightly acquainted with him," she said at length. " Will you oblige me with your name, sir," said the other, turning to Percy. " I don't know what my name has got to do with it ! " returned Percy, rather brusquely. " Who are you ? " The man turned back the lapel of his coat and showed the badge of the Central Detective Bureau. "I am attending to my business, sir," he said, " and as you were in this lady's company at the time the loss occurred you will be needed as a witness, if for no other purpose ! " He pronounced the last 48 A FATAL MEETING. words in a peculiar tone, which caused Percy to turn upon him sharply. " What do you mean by that ?" he demanded. " I mean, sir, that it is proper for me to make a note of your name," the detective replied. " I have no power, at present, to make you give it, however." "'Oh, I have no objection," Percy returned, care- lessly. " Here is my card," and he handed it to the other, who read it, nodded, and slipped it into his pocket. " Now, madam, what did you do after this gentleman spoke to you ? " "Tanswered him." " Did you still hold the money in your hand ? " " No," she said, after a moment's thought. " I took my hand out of the muff, and left it lying there on the counter." " Were the purse and the money still in it ? " "Yes." "Where was he standing ? " " He was facing me, on this side." " So your back was turned on your muff ? " " For a minute or two — yes." " Did any one approach you during that time ! " " Not that I remember. Of course, some one might have come up behind without my knowing of it." " What did you do next ? " " I think the salesman came up then, and I spoke to him about the necklace. He went off to. get it." A FATAL MEETING. 49 " And you continued your conversation with this gentleman ? " " Yes." " Was he in the same position as before ? " " No — yes — I don't remember ! " She had sud- denly became embarrassed, and the color flew into her cheeks again. She glanced at Percy with a frightened look. There was a short pause. " Does your memory serve you on that point, sir," inquired the detective, turning to Percy. " I have no particular recollection," lie replied ; " but I know that when the salesman came back with the necklace this lady was between me and the door, and I had her muff in my hands." " That agrees with my own impression," said the detective drily. " I happened to be looking at you at the time. Did you notice whether there was any thing in the muff at the time you were hold- ing it ? " " There was nothing in it. I put my hands inside, and if there had been any thing there I would have felt it." " When you first spoke to the lady, you were between her and the door. Afterwards, you went round to the other side of her. I want to be sure I have the details all right, you know. What was the occasion of your changing 'round ? " " I don't know. I wasn't thinking of what I was doing. While she was talking with the salesman I had nothing to occupy me ; I didn't even remem- ber that I touched the muff until you asked me." 50 A FATAL MEETING. The detective glanced over his tablets, and said, slowly :." The question is, how to reconcile the two facts : that the muff had the purse and money in it when you first spoke to the lady, and a few moments afterwards, when you had hold of it, it was empty." " I don't pretend to account for it ; that is your business, I suppose," Percy replied. " Of course, if the money was there, somebody must have taken it out." " Yes, sir, somebody must have taken it out," the detective repeated, fixing his eyes upon the young man. " Well, you don't mean to accuse me of it, I sup- pose," rejoined Percy, with a laugh. " I am not accusing any body, at present, sir. What does the lady think ? " " Oh, of course, that is impossible ! " said Mrs. Tunstall, looking much distressed. At this moment a gentleman entered the shop, glanced this way and that until he saw Mrs. Tun- stall, and then came straight toward her. As he approached, Percy recognized him ; it was Cuth- bert Tunstall. The two men bowed politely and coldly. CHAPTER VI. THE END OF AN INTRIGUE. WELL, Sylvia," said her husband, " have you transacted your business ?" She had been standing with her back toward him as he approached ; at the sound of his voice she gave a start, and faced him. Her face expressed alarm, agitation, and something of defi- ance. Tunstall, on the contrary, was quiet, cold, and slightly contemptuous in his bearing. It was certainly unfortunate that he should have come upon her and Percy together. For months past she had taken every precaution to avoid such a mishap, and now it had occurred, nor had any advantage accrued as between her and Percy, but quite the reverse. " I came in here to pay for the necklace, you know," she said. " I know. If you have paid for it, I am ready to escort you home — unless you have some engage- ment with this gentleman." " Oh, I have no engagement. Mr. Nolen hap- pened to come in and find me here. But — " " Then perhaps Mr. Nolen will excuse us." 52 THE END OF AN INTRIGUE. " But, I have just found — I have mislaid my pocket-book." "Left it at home?" " No, I have lost it since I came in here." " Do you mean it has been stolen from you ? " " It seems to have been. I can't account for it." " If you will step this way, madam, and gentle- men," put in the detective, "we can talk over the matter in private. There is a parlor at the back, where we shall not be disturbed. You understand, sir," he added, addressing Tunstall, " that time is of importance in such things, and the sooner we can take measures to capture the thief, the bet- ter chance there is to recover the bank-notes." " Let us go in, by all means." said Tunstall. " But in what manner is Mr. Nolen concerned." " I was here when the robbery was committed — if there was a robbery," said Percy, "and, accord- ing to this detective, my assistance is neces- sary." The detective pushed a way through the crowd that had collected, and led the others to the rear part of the building, where there was a small room with chairs and a table. Into this room were ad- mitted Mr. and Mrs. Tunstall, Percy, and the sales- man. " Now, then," said the detective, shutting the door, and taking up a position with his back toward it, " plain words don't break any bones, and the best thing we can do is to clear away whatever may look puzzling. Here's the way the case stands : THE END OF AN INTRIGUE. 53 Mrs. Tunstall comes into the shop with her hands in her muff, and four bank-notes to the amount of two thousand five hundred dollars were inside, together with the purse. She comes up to the counter, and this gentleman," pointing to Nolen, " comes in right after her, and speaks to her. While she is talking with him, she lays her muff, with the money and the purse in it, on the counter, and turns her back on it. After a while, along comes the salesman, and while she is speaking to him this gentleman goes round the other side and takes up her muff, and turns it in his hands, as it were. A minute afterwards she takes the muff from him, and finds that the money and the purse are gone. The gentleman says he had his hands in the muff, and that it was empty. That's how the case stands. Now, I want to know if the gen- tleman has any thing more to say." And he Iqpked at Nolen. " I have told all I know about it," replied Percy steadily. " I found the muff empty, and if Mrs. Tunstall had not been so positive that the purse and the money were in it I should say she must have been mistaken. The bank-notes might have fallen on the ground and not been noticed, but the purse would have been heard to drop." " May I ask, then, what your theory is ? " in- quired Tunstall, courteously. " I have none," he answered shortly. " And what is yours, Sylvia ? " her husband con- tinued. 54 THE END OF AN INTRIGUE. "I'm sure I don't know what to think," she said in a faltering voice. The eyes of Tunstall and the detective fixed themselves upon Percy in silence. He reddened as he returned the gaze, but whether with anger or with some other emotion it was impossible to determine. " Well," he broke out at length, " it seems to me that I stand in the position of a suspected person. I can hardly believe, >v he added, in a hoarser voice, " that I can be seriously charged with picking a lady's pocket — especially a lady with whom I am acquainted." He paused ; no one spoke. " Well, then," he went on, angrily, •' I will say that I repu- diate the charge, and I will hold to account who- ever has the face to make it. I mean you, sir ! " he said, with a fierce look at Tunstall. " Have you any thing to say to it ? " " So far as I am aware," said Tunstall, coolly, " the only person who has spoken of charging you with the theft is yourself. I was not present, and can only judge from hearsay. But I will say this, Mr. Nolen ; if I were in your place, I should wish to vindicate my innocence in some other way than by asserting it. I should begin by asking this de- tective to search my pockets." " Do you dare to say you want me to be searched ? " cried Nolen, his face flushing red, while he advanced a step toward the other, with a threat- ening gesture. " That is what an honest man would wish to have done," replied the other, not flinching. THE END OF AN INTRIGUE. 55 u Come, come," said the detective, stepping between them, " we don't want any hard words here, gentlemen. But I'm bound to tell you, Mr. Nolen, that Mr. Tunstall is right. There's no dis- grace in being searched, that I know of ; and it would be worth more than a lot of loud talking." Percy stood uncertain for a moment ; then he stripped off his overcoat, and tossed it to the detec- tive. " Do as you like," said he. " You have your duty to perform, I suppose. I will settle with Mr. Tunstall afterwards." The detective put his hand into one of the side- pockets of the overcoat, then into the other. " Here's something, at any rate," he remarked ; and with the words he drew out a lady's purse. Percy uttered a cry, as of utter astonishment and dismay, and stared at the pocket-book like a man bewildered. " Is that yours, Sylvia?" inquired her husband quietly, taking the purse and handing it to her. She took it mechanically and opened it. " It is mine," she said, under her breath. " Are the notes in it ? " demanded the detective. She shook her head. " They are not in the overcoat," the detective added. " We shall have to pursue our examination a little further, Mr. Nolen," he said, in a grave tone. " I don't understand — I have nothing to say — there seems to have been some plot against me," said Percy, in a dazed manner. " I desire to have 56 THE END OF AN INTRIGUE. the thing cleared up more than any one else can. I wish to be taken to the station and examined." " That's the best sense you've talked yet," answered the other, approvingly. " Call a couple of hacks, Ferris," he said to the salesman, " and we'll start at once. You charge this man on sus- picion of the robbery ? " he added, turning to Mrs. Tunstall. She was standing with her eyes cast down, and her hands hanging folded before her, leaning against the table. She was in a delicate position, and she knew it. If she sided with Percy, it would be tantamount to a defiance of her husband — a defiance which he would never forgive, and would fight out to the bitter end. It would mean, for her, loss of social position, and consequent exile and obscurity, or, if not obscurity, a kind of promi- nence that no one would envy her. If, on the other hand, she took sides with her husband, it would afford the strongest possible indication, in his eyes, of her virtuous and wifely conduct and rebuke of the suspicions he had entertained against her. Moreover, the evidence against Percy was very strong and plausible. It might be misleading — and, in the bottom of her heart, she did not believe him guilty — but, in case it should turn out that he had yielded to some sudden temptation, it would be awkward, to say the least, to have com- promised herself for a felon. Had she loved him, indeed, there might have been a tragic pleasure in sacrificing herself ; but it was now revealed to her THE END OF AN INTRIGUE. 57 that the only love in the matter was a love, not of Percy, but of excitement. The excitement had run itself out, and was succeeded by a desire to get out of the scrape by the shortest route. But did she feel no remorse at abandoning her lover at the moment of his greatest need ? No ; the feminine conscience is not so easily caught. It was with a glow of conscious virtue and connubial rectitude that she lifted her pretty face, and addressing her husband, said. " Well, I suppose he must have done it. I don't see who else could have. Yes, I will make the complaint, though it will be very disagreeable to appear in a court, among a lot of criminals ! " She just glanced at Percy as she turned away, perhaps to see how he would take it. His eyes were fixed upon her with an expression of half- incredulous curiosity ; but the next moment he threw back his head and burst into a loud laugh. She shrank a little at that sound, and edged toward the door ; and this was the lovers' parting scene. Such was the train of events that brought a young gentleman who might have made a good and respectable figure in the world to the office of Inspector Byrnes at Police Headquarters. The Inspector listened to the story, contemplating the prisoner and his accusers dreamily in the mean- while ; and after it was told, he sat for a while ab- sently making lines on the blotting-pad in front of him with the point of a paper-knife. Finally he looked up and briefly requested that 5 8 THE END OF AN INTRIGUE. every one should withdraw except Mrs. Tunstall and Percy Nolen. When the three were alone together, he regarded Mrs. Tunstall pensively and said, " How long have you known the prisoner ? " " Oh, a year or more." " Has your husband approved of the acquaint- ance ? " " How do you mean, sir ? " inquired the lady with a blush. " You know what I mean, I think." " I don't think my husband has ever liked Mr. Nolen," she replied uneasily. " Considered him rather detrimental, I sup- pose ? " By William Allingham. Beautifully Illustrated. 3s. 6d. The Little Doings of some Little Folks. By Chatty Cheer- ful. Illustrated. 5s. The Sunday Scrap Book. With One Thousand Scripture Pictures. Boards, 5s.; cloth, 7s. 6d. Daisy Dimple's Scrap Book. Containing about i.ooo Pictures. Boards, 5s.; cloth gilt, 7s. 6d. The History Scrap Book: With nearly 1,000 Engravings; 5s.; cloth, 7s. 6d. Little Folks' Picture Album. With 168 Large Pictures. 5s. Little Folks' Picture Gallery. With 150 Illustrations. 5s. Books for Boys. The Black Arrow. A Tale of the Two Roses. By R. L. Stevenson. 5s. Commodore Junk. By G. Man- villeFenn. 5s. A Queer Race. By W. Westall. Dead Man's Rock. A Romance. ByQ. 5s. The Phantom City. By W. Wes- tall. 5s. Captain Trafalgar : A Story of the Mexican Gulf. By Westall and Laurie. Illustrated. 5s. Kidnapped. By R. L. Stevenson. Illustrated. 5s. The Old Fairy Tales. With Original Illustrations. Boards, Is.; cloth, Is. 6d. My Diary. With 12 Coloured Plates and 366 Woodcuts. Is. Sandford and Merton: In Words of One Syllable. Illustrated. 2s. 6d. The Story of Robin Hood. With Coloured Illustrations. 2s. 6d. The Pilgrim's Progress. With Coloured Illustrations. 2s. 6d. Wee Little Rhymes. Is. 6d. Little One's Welcome. Is. 6d. Little Gossips. Is. 6d. Ding Dong Bell. Is. 6d. Good Times. Is. 6d. Jolly Little Stories. Is. 6d. Daisy Dell's Stories. Is. 6d. Our Little Friends. Is. 6d. Little Toddlers. Is. 6d. King Solomon's Mines. By H. Rider Haggard. Illustrated. 5s. Treasure Island. By R. L. Ste- venson. Illustrated. 5s. Ships, Sailors, and the Sea. By R. J. Cornewall-Jones. Illustrated. 5s. Modern Explorers. By Thomas Frost. Illustrated. 5s. Famous Sailors of Former Times. By Clements Markham. Illustrated. Wild'Adventures in Wild Places. By Dr. Gordon Stables, R.N. Illus- trated. 5s. Jungle, Peak, and Plain. By Dr. Gordon Stables, R.N. Illustrated. 5s. Cassell & Company's Complete Catalogue will be sent post free on application to CASSELL & COMPANY, LIMITED, Ludgatc Hill. London. 7